Cheryl Jarvis does some Reviewing of Reviews
A GREAT bit of writing from author Cheryl Jarvis, looking at the various reviews her book received. Jarvis wrote a nonfiction book, The Marriage Sabbatical: The Journey that Brings You Home, that told the stories of women who took time away from domestic life to pursue their passion. She then stayed away from all reviews of the book for six months. At that point, she printed up every review she could find, to see what people had to say.
If you’re an author, by all means read her article in Publisher’s Weekly:
It will offer you perspective, the next time some bonehead who hasn’t read your book says something completely stupid on Amazon, or the reviewer in PW notes that “this is good if you like this sort of thing.” (I particularly like the conservative talk show host who scorched the book, then admitted he’d never even seen a copy.) What’s clear is that “journalistic integrity” has little to do with the world of reviewers. Worth reading!
Sad (especially from Christians), but eyeopening. Thanks.
Sad, but not unusual, Josh.
Thanks for posting this, Chip. I had no idea people would be audacious enough to “review” books they hadn’t read. Wowzer.
Yeah — a bit of an eye-opener. Loved her story about the radio host admitting he hadn’t even seen the book!